Fuzzy的隶属度可以理解为概率吗?

答案是不可以,隶属度虽然也在[0,1]内,但和概率不是一码事。
一个很好的reddit blog解释如下:
Fuzzy logic and probability address different forms of uncertainty. While both fuzzy logic and probability theory can represent degrees of certain kinds of subjective belief, fuzzy set theory uses the concept of fuzzy set membership, i.e., how much a variable is in a set (there is not necessarily any uncertainty about this degree), and probability theory uses the concept of subjective probability, i.e., how probable is it that a variable is in a set (it either entirely is or entirely is not in the set in reality, but there is uncertainty around whether it is or is not). The technical consequence of this distinction is that fuzzy set theory relaxes the axioms of classical probability, which are themselves derived from adding uncertainty, but not degree, to the crisp true/false distinctions of classical Aristotelian logic.

也有人将probability(包括 Bayesian 和 frequentist)和fuzzy进行了比较:
From the readings above, I conclude that Fuzzy logic and probability (in general) are different ways to reason about different kinds of uncertainty, but Fuzzy and Bayesian logic share similar concepts, such as degree of belief/truthness. Bayesian probability seems more complete and consistent, but it seems that this is a matter of dispute.
On a practical note, if I have data, any kind of data, I will go with (Bayesian) probability. If I have vague or uncertain human procedures, I will go with Fuzzy logic. For example, if you have a process control problem where you have the knowledge of an operator who controls it manually but no system model (which would be highly nonlinear and multivariate), how would you solve this using Bayesian inference? With Fuzzy control it's really easy, and that is actually what the company I work for does.

以上内容简而言之,Fuzzy理论,概率论是从不同角度刻画不确定性的两种方法,数据多的情况下go with Bayesian probability,若涉及到人类的模糊性的时候go with Fuzzy logic。目前我了解的刻画不确定性的数学工具有三种:

  1. Fuzzy Set
  2. Rough Set
  3. Probability
最后编辑于
©著作权归作者所有,转载或内容合作请联系作者
平台声明:文章内容(如有图片或视频亦包括在内)由作者上传并发布,文章内容仅代表作者本人观点,简书系信息发布平台,仅提供信息存储服务。

推荐阅读更多精彩内容

  • 噩梦中 拼命追赶我最喜欢的人怕再见不到她 拳脚相向阻拦我的亲人怕会伤害到他 心急如焚歇斯底里声嘶力竭中睁开眼 汗流...
    投射在角落的几米阳光阅读 1,794评论 1 0
  • 【香知蜜读704】2017/11/18星期六 荐书蜜友:海 张茹 文:艾小羊 每个人都有怂的时候 他坐在我对面,倾...
    自律时光阅读 4,580评论 0 1
  • 【丛林中,四下无人】 李大缸:出来吧,我早就发现你了。 蒙面人:我明明跟踪的如此小心,怎么会被你发现? 李大缸:你...
    Zzzzzzr阅读 2,767评论 2 7
  • 一這是創意之旅“心靈對話·寫作”第十五篇文字。 寫這篇的衝動是源於剛剛讀了幾十頁村上春樹的新書《我的職業是小說家》...
    鏡如阅读 2,338评论 1 1