The popular messaging service shows that Facebook’s efforts to fight fake news may fail

Jan 25th 2018

“THERE’S too much sensationalism, misinformation andpolarisation in the world today,” lamented Mark Zuckerberg, the boss of Facebook, recently. To improve things, the world’s largest social network will cut the amount of news in users’ feeds by a fifth and attempt to make the remainder more reliable by prioritising information from sources which users think are trustworthy.

Many publishers are complaining: they worry that their content will show up less in users’ newsfeeds, reducing clicks and advertising revenues. But the bigger problem with Facebook’s latest moves may be that they are unlikely to achieve much—at least if the flourishing of fake news on WhatsApp, the messaging app which Facebook bought in 2014 for$19bn, is any guide.

In more ways than one, WhatsApp is the opposite of Facebook. Whereas posts on Facebook can be seen by all of a user’s friends, WhatsApp’s messages are encrypted. Whereas Facebook’s newsfeeds are curated by algorithms that try to maximise the time users spend on the service, WhatsApp’s stream of messages is solely generated by users. And whereas Facebook requires a fast connection, WhatsApp is not very data-hungry.

encrypt: to change information from one form to another especially to hide its meaning

现在有很多假新闻，谣言在社交媒体上传播，Facebook就想通过减少在他们“朋友圈” 上的新闻推送来遏制这种情况，但是更严重的是在它在2014年购买的Whatsapp 

As a result, WhatsApp has become a social network to rival Facebook in many places, particularly in poorer countries. Of the service’s more than 1.3bn monthly users, 120m live in Brazil and 200m in India (see chart). With the exceptions of America, China, Japan and South Korea, WhatsApp is among the top three most-used social apps in all big countries.

Most of the 55bn messages sent every day are harmless, but WhatsApp’s scale attracts all sorts of mischief-makers. In South Africa the service is often used to spread false allegations of civic corruption and hoax warnings of storms, fires and other natural disasters. In Brazil rumours about people travel quickly: a mob recently set upon a couple they suspected of being child traffickers based on chatter on WhatsApp (the couple escaped).

hoax: an act that is meant to trick or deceive people

WhatsApp 已经是一款社交媒体平台，它和Facebook在很多方面有竞争冲突的地方，特别是在比较贫穷的国家。它有13亿月活跃用户，巴西有1.2亿用户，印度有2亿用户。当用户量达到这么大的时候，很多谣言就会在这款软件上传播地很快！

But it is in India where WhatsApp has had the most profound effect. It is now part of the country’s culture:many older people use it and drive younger ones crazy by forwarding messages indiscriminately—sometimes with tragic results. Last year, seven men in the eastern state of Jharkhand were murdered by angry villagers in two separate incidents after rumours circulated on WhatsApp warning of kidnappers in the area. In a gruesome coda to the incident, pictures and videos from thelynching also went viral.

It is unclear how exactly such misinformation spreads, not least because traffic is encrypted. “It’s not that we have chosen not to look at it. It is impossible,” says Filippo Menczer of Indiana University’s Observatory on Social Media, which tracks the spread of fake news on Twitter and other online services. Misinformation on WhatsApp is identified only when it jumps onto another social-media platform or, as in India, leads to tragic consequences.

gruesome: causing horror or disgust

lynch: to kill someone illegally as punishment for a crime

WhatsApp在印度的影响是最大的，因为印度的老年人也在用这款软件，而且经常传播一些谣言（是不是和微信里爸妈老一辈转发传播谣言是一模一样的！！） ，印度的年轻人深受其害，有时候还会发展为悲剧

Some patterns are becoming clear, however. Misinformation often spreads via group chats, which people join voluntarily and whose members—family, colleagues, friends, neighbours—they trust. That makes rumours more believable. Misinformation does not always come in the form of links, but often as forwarded texts and videos, which look the same as personal messages, lending them a further veneer of legitimacy. And since users often receive the same message in multiple groups, constant repetition makes them more believable yet.

Predictably, propagandists have employed WhatsApp as a potent tool. In “Dreamers”, a book about young Indians, Snigdha Poonam, a journalist, describes visiting a political party’s “social media war room” in 2014. Workers spent their days “packaging as many insults as possible into one WhatsApp message”, which would then be sent out to party members to be propagated within their own networks. Similar tactics are increasingly visible elsewhere. Last month’s conference in South Africa of the African National Congress, at which delegates elected a new party leader, saw a flood of messages claiming victory for and conspiracy by both factions. With elections due in Brazil and Mexico this year, and in India next year, expect more such shenanigans.

veneer: a thin layer of wood or other material that is attached to the surface of something in order to make it look better

为什么谣言传播那么快？有一点是清晰的，这些谣言一般来自群聊，群里的都是亲戚，朋友，邻居，都是互相信任的人，这使得谣言更像真的；还有一般这些谣言不是以链接形式出现，而是以文字，视频的形式出现，像发给朋友的私人信息一样，更加逼真

shenanigans: activity or behavior that is not honest or proper

Governments and WhatsApp itself are keenly aware of the problem. In India authorities now regularly block WhatsApp to stop the spread of rumours, for instance of salt shortages. Regulators in Kenya, Malaysia and South Africa have mooted the idea of holding moderators of group chats liable for false information in their groups. WhatsApp is working on changing the appearance of forwarded messages in the hope that visual cues will help users tell the difference between messages from friends and those of unknown provenance. But ultimately it will be down to users to be more responsible and not blindly forward messages they receive.

It is as yet unclear whether fake news on Facebook will be less of a problem after it changes its algorithms. The experience of WhatsApp suggests, however, that the concerns will persist. “Even with all these counter measures, the battle will never end,” Samidh Chakrabarti, a Facebook executive admitted on January 22nd. “Misinformation campaigns are not amateur operations. They are professionalised and constantly try to game the system.”

moot: to introduce (an idea, subject, etc.) for discussion 

政府和WhatsApp 都意识到了这个问题，印度已经开始经常屏蔽它，来减少谣言传播，要不然经常就闹盐荒。其他国家也出相应的措施，WhatsApp也开始标记那些没有经过证实的转发信息，最关键还是用户得谨慎转发这些信息

to game the system 这个用法记起来

总结：不怕社交媒体火起来，就怕中老年人也在玩，各国的中老年人都爱转发谣言，从QQ到微信，从中国到印度！

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Results

Lexile®Measure: 1200L - 1300L

Mean Sentence Length: 17.17

Mean Log Word Frequency: 3.13

Word Count: 790

这篇文章的蓝思值是在1200-1300L， 适合英语专业大三的水平学习，是经济学人里普通难度

使用kindle断断续续地读《经济学人》三年，发现从一开始磕磕碰碰到现在比较顺畅地读完，进步很大，推荐购买！点击这里可以去亚马逊官网购买~