1. What is your take-away message from this paper?（学到了什么？）

2. What is the motivation for this work (both people problem and technical problem), and its distillation into a research question? Why doesn’t the people problem have a trivial solution? What are the previous solutions and why are they inadequate?（动机是什么？）

3. What is the proposed solution (hypothesis, idea, design)? Why is it believed it will work? How does it represent an improvement? How is the solution achieved?（求解方法如何？）

4. What is the author’s evaluation of the solution? What logic, argument, evidence, artifacts (e.g., a proof-of-concept system), or experiments are presented in support of the idea?（怎么评估求解的）

5. What is your analysis of the identified problem, idea and evaluation? Is this a good idea? What flaws do you perceive in the work? What are the most interesting or controversial ideas? For work that has practical implications, ask whether this will work, who would want it, what it will take to give it to them, and when might it become a reality?（评估论文质量如何？）

6. What are the paper’s contributions (author’s and your opinion)? Ideas, methods, software, experimental results, exper-imental techniques...?（贡献在哪里？）

7. What are future directions for this research (author’s and yours, perhaps driven by shortcomings or other critiques ? （未来的进一步研究)

8. What questions are you left with? What questions would you like to raise in an open discussion of the work (review interesting and controversial points, above)? What do you find difficult to understand? List as many as you can.(开放会议的场景下，会提出什么问题？)